Skip to content
Day 12 voteLiveAPPEALDROP
Case file · Day 12 · Oct 28, 2026 · 1:42

The Judge

Hermes told YouTube the song was his. Four minutes later, Apollo answered.

At dawn in Athena's vast marble archives, Hermes sits on a reading table typing on his glowing phone while Athena watches him over her round golden glasses from a stone lectern under the skylight, an owl on her shoulder.
The vote
Day 12 · Vote open

Appeal to the same judge and risk a strike, or drop it and let every view pay Apollo?

APPEALvsDROP

Comment APPEAL or DROP on the episode. Instagram, TikTok and YouTube all count.

Closes Oct 29, 2026 · 1pm ET

Case file · Where it stands
Followers
15600
Earned
€0
Days left
19
What happened

You voted, and DISPUTE won. At 6 a.m., in Athena's archives, Hermes disputes Apollo's claim on his video. His reason: I have all the rights. He made the first lyre, he says, so every song on it is his. Athena gives him one piece of advice: read who reviews it, twice. Hermes never reads twice. He hits send.

At 6:01, at Apollo's villa, a golden tablet lights up beside Apollo's breakfast. Little brother says my song is his, Apollo smiles. How sweet. At 6:05, as Hermes crosses the agora, a notification: dispute rejected, claim reinstated. It took four minutes. But who reads a dispute in four minutes?

Here is the trap: YouTube says it can't make ownership determinations. So when you dispute a Content ID claim, the one who reviews it is the claimant. Here, Apollo. He has 30 days to answer a dispute, and he can release the claim, reinstate it, or ask for the video's removal.

By noon, the agora has picked a side, and Hermes gains two thousand followers. One button is left: appeal. Apollo has seven days to answer an appeal too, and he says he'll do it on Halloween. If he rejects it, he can request the removal of the video, and a valid removal request means a copyright strike.

Now the choice: appeal, and Apollo judges again. Drop it, and the claim stays, and every view pays Apollo. Then, at 9 p.m., Ares names his price for making Apollo let go. Leave your back door open. Those are not his words. Someone said them first, on day ten.

The evidence · The story is fiction. These rules are real.
  1. The claimant reviews your dispute

    YouTube says the initial dispute and the appeal are both reviewed by the claimant, because YouTube can't make ownership determinations. The claimant has 30 days to respond to a dispute: they can release the claim, reinstate it, or submit a copyright removal request.

  2. An appeal gives the claimant seven days

    When you appeal a rejected dispute, the claimant is notified and has 7 days to respond. If they submit a valid copyright removal request, your video is removed from YouTube and your channel gets a copyright strike.

  3. The god who made the first lyre

    The Homeric Hymn to Hermes says it was Hermes who first made the tortoise a singer, turning its shell into the first lyre, and that he later held out the lyre to Apollo, who took it.

All the rules behind the story

Halloween offer

31% off your first year

Every paid plan includes the Olympus Pass: your @ in the Pantheon.

Annual plans, new subscribers only, code HALLOWEEN26. Until Sunday, November 1, 11:59 pm Paris time.

Black Friday

50% off your first year

Every paid plan includes the Olympus Pass: your @ in the Pantheon.

Annual plans, new subscribers only, code BLACKFRIDAY26. Until Monday, November 30, 11:59 pm Paris time.

Holiday offer

30% off your first year

Every paid plan includes the Olympus Pass: your @ in the Pantheon.

Annual plans, new subscribers only, code NOEL26. Until Saturday, December 26, 11:59 pm Paris time.